|
Benign intracranial hypertension is a condition wherein there is
intracranial hypertension with no demonstrable mass or any other
abnormality.
Three names are
in use today, pseudotumor cerebri, idiopathic intracranial hypertension
and benign intracranial hypertension.
It is a
diagnosis of exclusion. There is no single test or procedure leading to
the correct diagnosis of this syndrome.
Historically BIH
was referred to, as brain swelling of unknown cause, otitic or toxic
hydrocephalus, pseudoabscess, hypertensive meningela hydrops or serous
meningitis.
Epidemiology:
BIH is a rare disease. There are no reliable epidemiological data. It
occurs in any age group including children and infants; but is most common
in obese young females between 25 and 35 years of age. The mean age at
onset of symptoms is about 30 years. 80-90% is woman, and most of them are
obese (mean weight 90 kg). Some studies suggest an annual incidence rate
of 1 per 100,000. In the high-risk group of obese woman in the
reproductive age-group, the annual incidence rate is suggested to be about
20 per 100,000 people.
Etiology:
The etiology of
BIH remains obscure. Because of the different pathophysiology and
prognosis BIH is considered separate from conditions producing symptoms
identical to benign intracranial hypertension, such as chronic
meningoencephalitis venous sinus thrombophlebitis, congestive
intrathoracic lesions, polyradiculitis and spinal cord tumors.
The most consistent finding in patients with BIH is obesity (40-80% of all
patients). Mostly a marked weight gain has been observed several months
before the symptoms occurred. Hormonal changing periods (menarche,
pregnancy, oestrogen therapy) and signs of hormonal dysfunction (hypertrichiasis,
sometimes galactorrhoea) are often associated with BIH. Therefore it has
been supposed that endocrine dysfunction may be a cause of BIH but up to
now there is little supporting evidence. Occasionally drugs are suggested
to cause BIH, e.g. tetracycline, nalidixic acid or vitamin A (usually to
treat acne in adolescents or young women). Vitamin deficiency may also be
involved in the development of BIH, especially vitamin A and B12.
Pathophysiological
considerations:
We know little
about the pathophysiological mechanism leading to the symptomatology.
The pathophysiology of genuine BIH is still discussed controversially.
Increased brain water content, increased cerebral blood volume and
increased outflow resistance to CSF have all been suggested.
Increased brain water content of about 4% was found in a study. It is
attributed to intracellular and/or extracellular swelling and leads to a
decrease in craniospinal compliance which counteracts ventricular
dilatation. The increased brain water content renders the brain less
compressible. Thus there will be in case of increased resistance to CSF
outflow a high pressure but no enlargement of the ventricles. The result
is a diminished total CSF volume and a ventricular size that is even
smaller than normal. In the pathophysiological concept of Malm extracellular edema causes partial compression of the major venous sinus
with consequent rise in sagittal sinus pressure as one mechanism for the
development of increased CSF pressure.
Increased cerebral blood volume (CBV), according to the current knowledge,
is found in the majority of cases. It is the result of cerebral
vasodilatation or increased intracranial pressure, which leads to an
increase in pressure in the veins traversing the sub arachnoid space with a consequent rise in total CBV.
Increased resistance to outflow of CSF is according to the current
pathogenic hypothesis the basic defect in the development of BIH. The
increased resistance may be caused by congenitally fewer arachnoid
absorptive channels or acquired structural changes in the arachnoid villi.
Now the symptoms of intracranial hypertension may develop by:
Further
increase in resistance at the level of the villi (e.g. caused by steroid
withdrawal, female sex hormone changes, pituitary-adrenal dysfunction,
hypo para-thyroidism, tetracycline or nalidixic acid therapy), leading
to interstitial brain water accumulation and elevation of CSF pressure.
Intracellular
brain water accumulation caused by agents or events interfering with
membrane structure or function and brain water permeability (e.g. head
injury, anemia, vasopressin, or other endocrine dysfunctions).
Both mechanisms will bring about a rise in intracranial pressure until the
CSF absorptive level for the new equilibrium of CSF dynamics is reached.
In
some, the BIH syndrome may represent a response to some exogenous factors
and endogenous physiological alterations.
Such
conditions include:
Intracranial venous drainage occlusion (mastoiditis and lateral sinus
obstruction, paranasal sinus and phayngeal infections, congenital
atresia or stenosis of venous sinuses, extracerebral mass lesions, head
injury, polycythemia vera).
Cervical or thoracic venous drainage obstruction (intrathoracic mass
lesions and postoperative obstruction of venous return).
Endocrine dysfunction (pregnancy, menarche, oral contraceptives,
obesity, Addison's disease, hypothyroidism).
Hematological disorders (acute iron deficiency anemia, pernicious
anemia, thrombocytopenia).
Vitamin metabolism (hyper/hypo vitaminosis A, vitamin D deficiency).
Reaction to drugs such as tetracycline, penicilin, sulfamethoxazole,
indomethacin, nalidixic acid, and prophylactic antisera.
Galactosemia, galactokinase deficiency, sydenham's chorea, sarcoidosis,
and Turner's syndrome are some of the rarer associated conditions.
Symptoms:
Suggested
criteria for BIH include, the symptoms of increased intracranial pressure
(ICP), papilledema and ICP values of more than 20 mmHg, and absence of
focal neurological signs, except those typically for raised ICP, such as a
sixth nerve palsy. There is no symptomatic epilepsy and no impairment of
consciousness; normal composition of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF); no mass
lesion or hydrocephalus on CT scan.
The typical clinical picture of BIH is that of a young or middle aged
obese woman with headache and sometimes impaired vision. Dizziness,
nausea, vomiting, tinnitus and hearing loss are occasional associated
symptoms. rarely there is CSF
rhinorrhoea.
The symptoms of increased intracranial pressure are often intermittent but
usually with a history of less than one year. In contrast to
space-occupying lesions the symptoms of patients with BIH are usually less
pronounced. In addition patients with BIH are characterized by greater
daily variations of their complaints, i.e. every day they feel different.
Signs of lethargy, decreased activity or disturbances of consciousness are
usually missing. Patients with BIH often do not see the doctor until they
suffer from marked visual impairment.
Children present
with diplopia due to 6th nerve paresis which is a secondary sign due to
increased ICP.
In infants,
progressive increase in the size of the head with bulging fontanels is is
presenting symptom.
Diagnostic evaluation:
BIH is a diagnostic syndrome and no single test leads to the correct
diagnosis.
Fundi examination reveals
papilledema. Neurological examination usually reveals no focal
neurological signs except those which are typical for raised intracranial
pressure such as
sixth
nerve palsy (10%), slight gait disturbance and ataxia mostly due to
dizziness. The
IIIrd
and the Vth cranial nerve involvement and visual field defect can be
observed rarely.
Chronic
meningoencephalitis, venous sinus thrombophlebitis, congestive
intrathoracic lesions, polyradiculitis and spinal cord tumors may produce
symptoms identical to BIH. These conditions must be ruled out before the
diagnosis of benign intracranial hypertension can be established.
CT & MRI:
The symptoms of increased intracranial hypertension demand a CT or MRI to
exclude a mass lesion or hydrocephalus. The typical finding is a
ventricular system of normal or diminished size (Evans ratio < 0.25 the
width of the frontal horns divided by the maximum internal skull
diameter). Enlarged optic nerve sheaths can be observed on the computed
tomograms of the orbit. Attention must be paid to the patency of the
sinus thrombosis and thus symptomatic intracranial hypertension. In about
10-40% of patients with BIH an empty sella is diagnosed , and occasionally a neurodegenerative disease can be revealed. CT
or MRI must be performed before a lumbar puncture is considered.
Lumbar puncture:
The examination of CSF is compulsory to exclude symptomatic forms of
intracranial hypertension. In BIH the typical findings are completely
normal values of protein, glucose and cells. The diagnosis requires the
demonstration of significantly increased ICP > 20 mmHg.
Normally it is sufficient to measure ICP by Lumbar pressure measurement
over a period of 30-120 min. This minimally invasive procedure enables
one to recognize steady state increased ICP and abnormal pressure waves.
In BIH lumbar pressure correlates very well with pressure values recorded
on other sites, provided that a strictly flat lateral recumbent position
is maintained. If there is any doubt of the quality of the recorded
pressure, other forms of pressure measurements with overnight recording of
ICP must be used.
Visual assessment:
Visual fields, intraocular pressure measurement, fundus photographs and
visual acuity are performed, since the most serious sequel of BIH is
permanent visual loss due to the chronic papilledema. BIH is a cause of
progressive visual loss in children and young adults.
Papilledema (95% <10% unilateral, dioptres mostly ranging from 1.0 to
4.0), visual obscurations or blurring of vision (80%), double vision
(20%), partial visual field loss (20%), enlarged blind spots (90%) and
loss of central vision are common. The results of these investigations
determine the therapeutic procedure and the urgency of treatment .
Measurement of CSF
outflow resistance (R):
Provides specific diagnostic information in BIH. It can
be performed by means of lumbar infusion. Computerized infusion tests
should be preferred to reduce duration and plateau pressure as well as to
increase accuracy. R is found to be increased up to 50 mmHG/min/ml. Mean
R ranges are 12 to 35 mmHg/min/ml. However, there is no correlation
between ICP and R.
ICP recording:
ICP overnight
recording reveals an increased intracranial pressure (>15 mmHg) with
plateau-waves in 30% of patients and B-waves in 90% of patients. There is
also a suggestion of transient episodes of raised ICP due to nocturnal
hypoxia and hypercarbia in some patients which may contribute to symptoms
such as papilledema and visual failure.
Management:
BIH is self
limiting with no sequelae in most.
Management of
patients with BIH should be based on the presence and progression of
visual loss.
BIH must be
treated, if rapid or progressive visual impairment occurs.
Hence,
treatment and follow-up must be performed together with an
ophthalmologist.
Treatment is
directed at the associated cause, if any (such as steroids in Addison's,
and iron in anemia).
Elimination of
exogenous factors
and endogenous physiological alterations, promptly gives relief.
Acetazolamide
and/or
Frusemide
is given for a period of 6-24 months to lower CSF production.
Steroids for
about 2.4 weeks may be effective, but the bodyweight of obese young women
is frequently increasing, so that it should not be recommended as a
therapeutic measure of first choice. Many physicians question the role of
steroids.
Drug therapy
provides temporary improvement but fails in approximately one third of
cases. Despite all the measures above, impress upon the patient the
necessity to lose weight.
Lumbar puncture
is also only a temporary measure, but it can easily be performed to
relieve the symptoms in the acute phase. Furthermore it is compulsory for
diagnostic evaluation, i.e. to exclude pathological composition of CSF as
a possible cause of intracranial hypertension and to measure outflow
resistance.
Shunting
provides long lasting CSF pressure reduction. It can be carried out as a
lumboperitoneal shunt, or
ventriculo-peritoneal/atrial
shunt.
Decompressive
procedures to prevent further visual loss are frequently needed.
Presently, optic
nerve sheath decompression is the treatment of choice in patients with
visual loss, but this does not alleviate the increased ICP or its other
symptoms of increased ICP. However it improves visual function in about
70% of all operated eyes in acute papilledema and 30% in chronic
papilledema. Repeated optic nerve sheath decompression or optic nerve
fenestration should be considered in cases of persistent recurring
symptoms.
CSF draining
into the orbit has been hypothesized as its mechanism of action. But orbit
can not accommodate all the CSF. pulse pressure damping may have a role.
resultant scarring around the nerve may protect the nerve; but this can
not explain the improvement of the opposite nerve.
Sub
temporal decompression is less commonly performed nowadays.
Bilateral decompression may be required. It does not always prevent
further visual loss, and may result in contra-lateral partial seizures,
mostly beginning 6-12 months post-operatively.
Follow-up assessment
and prognosis
BIH is a self limiting disorder with a course of less than 12 months in
most cases. It is characterized by a high spontaneous remission rate and
a very good long term prognosis. After 1 to 4 years only 20% of all
patients formerly presenting with symptoms of elevated ICP are still
suffering from headache. The other signs usually disappear completely.
Sometimes however it runs a protracted course, with recurring symptoms.
In
less than 50% the papilledema resolves and the majority develops chronic
disc changes, e.g. about 50% develop optic disc gliosis. Rarely,
permanent visual loss is seen in patients with BIH.
It
is of clinical importance to emphasize that after the disappearance of the
symptoms the physiological abnormalities remain. The main parameters (ICP,
R) tend toward the normal values but do not reach them. A sustained
increased ICP is seen in about 60% of cases (i.e. > 15 mmHg) despite the
well-being of the patients. Even more astonishing is the fact that
measurements of R up to 48 months after the time of chief complaints
continue to show increased values; in 80% of cases the R was >
12mmHg/min/ml. In follow up assessment, frusemide and acetazolmide must
be tapered off 2 weeks before infusion tests to obtain correct results in
ICP and R measurements. |